Kochi, Kerala

Kerala HC refers Punarjani case petition to Chief Justice

The petition challenges a vigilance report that dropped charges against the Chief Minister in the Punarjani flood rehabilitation project

Kerala HC refers Punarjani case petition to Chief Justice
Representative stock image (Pexels), not a photo of the reported event.
Share

A single bench of the Kerala High Court has referred a petition challenging the closure of a preliminary inquiry into Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan regarding the Punarjani flood rehabilitation project to the Chief Justice. Justice C. Jayachandran, presiding over the case, observed that there were strong prima facie indications that the petition bore the characteristics of a public interest litigation.

The court has directed the High Court Registry to place the matter before the Chief Justice. The purpose of this referral is to determine the appropriate forum for the case, specifically whether it should be heard by a court handling MP/MLA cases, a court dealing with the Prevention of Corruption Act, or if it should be treated as a PIL.

The petition was filed by lawyer K.M. Shajahan, who is challenging a report from the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB). The bureau had previously closed the inquiry and dropped corruption charges against the Chief Minister in relation to the Punarjani scheme. During the proceedings, the court examined two primary questions: whether the petitioner possessed the legal right to challenge the inquiry report, and whether the court held the necessary jurisdiction to hear the matter.

Representing the petitioner, counsel argued that the plea was filed in the capacity of a citizen and a whistleblower, asserting a right to contest the findings. Conversely, the State noted that a previous petition regarding the same case had been filed by a complainant and later withdrawn to be refiled as a PIL seeking a CBI investigation; that petition was subsequently dismissed by a division bench. The State contended that the current petitioner lacked the legal standing to pursue the matter further as the complaint had already been addressed by the court. Justice Jayachandran concluded that the issue of jurisdiction must be resolved before addressing the petitioner’s legal rights.

Key facts

  • The petitioner is lawyer K.M. Shajahan.
  • The case involves the Punarjani flood rehabilitation scheme.
  • Justice C. Jayachandran heard the matter at the Kerala High Court.
  • The Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau had previously closed the preliminary inquiry.
  • The referral follows a dispute over whether the case qualifies as a public interest litigation.

Source: The Hindu

Found this helpful? Share it.

Comments

Comments are reviewed before they appear.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!