Pune, Maharashtra

Jimmy Tata alleges 'backdoor takeover' of group by Noel Tata

Long-serving trustee calls for immediate listing of Tata Sons to ensure transparency and regulatory accountability

Jimmy Tata alleges 'backdoor takeover' of group by Noel Tata
Representative stock image (Pexels), not a photo of the reported event.
Share

Jimmy Naval Tata, a long-serving trustee of the Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) and younger half-brother of the late Ratan Tata, has levelled serious allegations against Noel Tata regarding the governance of Tata Trusts. In a written response to a senior trustee, Jimmy Tata claimed that the induction of multiple family members into the trusts constitutes a “back-door takeover” of Tata Sons, the group’s holding company.

The 85-year-old trustee argued that the current trend of filling trusts with family members of the present chairman violates the original intentions of the settlors, Sir Ratan Tata and Sir Dorabji Tata. He stated that the charitable trusts were established for public welfare and that trustees act as custodians of assets rather than owners. According to Jimmy Tata, having more than one family member on a trust is inappropriate and undermines the independence of these institutions.

Jimmy Tata further criticised changes to the Tata Sons’ Articles of Association, which occurred around 2013-14. He stated that these amendments fundamentally altered the relationship between the charitable trusts and the commercial operations of the group. He alleged that the changes provided the Tata Trusts chairman with veto powers and the authority to appoint directors, thereby weakening the board's collective authority. Furthermore, he noted that these governance shifts have enabled the marginalisation of dissenting trustees, citing the case of Venu Srinivasan.

In contrast to the current disputes, Jimmy Tata expressed support for the leadership of Tata Sons chairman N Chandrasekaran. He noted that Chandrasekaran has managed to turn around debt-burdened companies and provided record earnings. Jimmy Tata alleged that Noel Tata attempted to block Chandrasekaran’s reappointment by invoking veto provisions without sufficient justification, despite the move receiving support from the Tata Sons board and a resolution from Tata Trusts.

To resolve the ongoing governance rifts, Jimmy Tata urged the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to enforce the listing of Tata Sons. He argued that listing the company is essential to improving accountability, dismantling a culture of secrecy, and restoring the separation between the group's welfare trusts and commercial operations. He warned against any efforts to restructure Tata Sons to avoid these regulatory requirements, stating such actions would be contrary to shareholder interests.

Key facts

  • Jimmy Naval Tata has been a trustee of the Sir Ratan Tata Trust since 1989.
  • Tata Trusts collectively holds approximately 66% of Tata Sons, with SRTT accounting for 23.56%.
  • The RBI has classified Tata Sons as an upper-layer non-banking financial company, requiring it to list on a stock exchange.
  • Jimmy Tata holds a 0.81% stake in Tata Sons, comprising 3,262 shares.
  • The Sir Ratan Tata Trust has three perpetual trustees: Jimmy Tata, Noel Tata, and Jehangir Jehangir.

Why it matters

The intervention by Jimmy Tata highlights an internal power struggle that could reshape the governance of one of India's largest conglomerates. The demand for the listing of Tata Sons, if enforced by the RBI, would force a major structural shift in how the holding company manages its relationship with the charitable trusts that control it.

Background

Jimmy Tata resides in Pune and has traditionally maintained a low profile, rarely attending meetings in person. Instead, he has historically utilised written correspondence to articulate his perspectives to the boards and trustees of the organisation.

Source: Economic Times

Found this helpful? Share it.

Comments

Comments are reviewed before they appear.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!